Why We Need Federal Preemption on AI: Protecting Consumers, Innovators, and the Future

By Alliance for the Future

Across the country, state legislatures are actively engaging in AI policymaking. Hundreds of AI-related bills have been introduced. This growing interest reflects how quickly artificial intelligence is becoming central to our economy, our society, and our daily lives.

Last night, the House Energy and Commerce Committee advanced reconciliation legislation that includes a federal moratorium on new state-level AI regulations. Alliance for the Future strongly supports this provision, and we thank Chairman Brett Guthrie (KY-02) for his leadership in moving this language through the committee.

A national pause on new state-level laws would give Congress time to create a unified and national AI policy framework that supports innovation, protects consumers, and keeps the U.S. globally competitive. During this time, states would have the opportunity to inform and shape that policy through hearings, consultations, and expert input.

Without a national framework, consumers may face different AI experiences depending on the state they live in. One product or service might be permitted in one state but restricted in another. This can create uncertainty for users, limit access to beneficial technologies, and reduce confidence in the tools they rely on.

Small businesses, startups, and research institutions working on AI will face real challenges operating across state lines if rules vary significantly by jurisdiction. These innovators are focused on solving real-world problems with limited resources. When legal expectations differ from one state to the next, it becomes harder for new ideas to scale or reach the people who need them. A federal approach gives them the clarity they need to build and grow responsibly.

This is a pivotal moment. We have a chance to get the policy framework right before the full weight of AI’s impact is felt. If a patchwork of laws takes hold before national guidelines are in place, we risk locking in confusion and creating long-term obstacles to progress. A temporary, targeted moratorium gives lawmakers the space to develop smart, enforceable federal standards informed by expert input from all levels of government.

This effort is focused solely on AI. It is not about broader tech or telecom issues. It is about ensuring that the next generation of AI tools can be developed and deployed under a consistent, constructive framework that benefits everyone.

Other countries are moving quickly. If the United States allows fragmentation to take hold, we risk falling behind in both innovation and influence. A clear, stable national approach will encourage responsible development, attract investment, and help ensure that American values shape the global future of AI.

We urge the House of Representatives to advance this commonsense language as part of its full reconciliation package and send it to the Senate without delay. A national framework for AI is essential to ensuring the United States leads the world in innovation, investment, and responsible deployment.

Let’s give our innovators room to build. Let’s give our communities confidence in what comes next.